Darwin in Egypt

bibliothecaFrom Salman Hameed of Irtiqa:

Two days have passed and the verdict is in. The quality of speakers (excluding some crazies) is phenomenal at the Darwin’s Living Legacy conference in Alexandria, Egypt. Some quick thoughts: There have been some anti-evolutionary comments made in the sessions that dealt with religion and evolution, but overall, the reception seems to have been quite positive—both in Egyptian newspapers and among the local participants. Ultimately, it is fantastic to see leading evolutionary biologists and historians of science presenting their cutting-edge research in Egypt!
Excluding the people on my panels, my two favorite talks so far: Richard Wrangham on his book Catching Fire: How Cooking Made Us Humans (basically arguing that pre-humans started to control fire and eat cooked food somewhere around 2.6 million years ago and that there is good evidence for the resultant reduced gut size and reduction in molars by 1.6 million years ago, somewhere between Homo habilis and Homo erectus) and James Secord on Darwinism and the global circulation of news (stressing the importance of newspapers in the dissemination of Darwin’s ideas, though he talked about a number of other things, including the first Arabic translation of Origins in 1918—pretty late, but not as late as in Turkish in 1970).
Yes, there have been some depressing moments as well. In particular, the TV debate organized by BBC Arabic. It featured Nidhal Guessoum, Ramez Maluf, and … and … and … Zaghloul El-Naggar. If you are wondering who Zaghloul El-Naggar is, well, he was responsible for the bizarre Al Jazeera coverage of the discovery of Ardi—and yes, he made plenty of crazy claims in the debate as well. The debate was in Arabic, but I listened to it via (bad) live translation into English. I think a discussion between Guessoum and Maluf, and a subsequent interaction with the audience, would have been terrific and probably would have brought out a discussion not only of evolution but also about other science-related topics. However, the presence of El-Naggar totally polarized the debate and evoked an equally polarizing reaction from the audience.
What a waste of an opportunity. But this craziness has been balanced by a very high quality of talks.

Category: Blog Network


Leave a Reply